Nicola Sirchia

Comebacks / Abercrombie & Fitch

How did Abercrombie & Fitch go from most hated to record sales?

By Nicola Sirchia. Published . 2 minute read.

The short answer

In 2016 a national customer satisfaction index ranked Abercrombie & Fitch among the most hated retailers in the United States. Fran Horowitz became chief executive in February 2017 and rebuilt the brand around inclusion instead of exclusion. Sales stayed flat for years, then rose to a record $5.27bn in the 2025 financial year, the first above $5bn.

The fall

2016

among the most hated retailers in America

The comeback

$5.27bn

record sales in its 2025 financial year

What went wrong at Abercrombie & Fitch?

The old Abercrombie sold belonging by refusing it. The shops were dark and heavy with perfume, shirtless models stood at the door, and the marketing told most shoppers they were not cool enough for the clothes.

It worked for a generation and then turned against the brand. By the middle of the 2010s sales were falling by double digits, shops were closing and the company was close to being sold.

How did Abercrombie & Fitch come back?

Horowitz had joined in 2014 to run Hollister. As chief executive she widened the range of sizes, changed the shops, and gave each brand in the group its own identity again after they had blurred together.

The results took time. Revenue sat near $3.3bn for years. The first signs came at the end of 2019, and then the numbers moved: $4.28bn in 2023, $4.95bn in 2024 and $5.27bn in 2025, with fourteen quarters of growth in a row.

Abercrombie & Fitch Co. net sales by financial year

2017$3.30bn
2023$4.28bn
2024$4.95bn
2025$5.27bn
In $bn. Source: FashionUnited.

Abercrombie & Fitch in dates

  1. 2014Fran Horowitz joins to run Hollister
  2. 2015The sexualised advertising ends
  3. 2016Ranked among the most hated US retailers
  4. Feb 2017Horowitz becomes chief executive
  5. Late 2019First signs of the turnaround
  6. 2025Record sales of $5.27bn

What was marketing's role?

My judgement: Decisive

Marketing changed who the brand was for. The sexualised advertising had already ended in 2015. The new brand stopped chasing cool, a word the chief executive has said the company no longer aims for, and set out to appeal to a different generation. The product followed the positioning: sizes and fits for more bodies. It is rare to see a brand reverse its central promise and survive it.

What do I take from it?

A brand built on excluding people was rebuilt on including them, and it took years. Most turnaround stories leave that part out. Whoever starts one needs a board that will wait.

Sources: FashionUnited, Inside Retail, Modaes