Nicola Sirchia

Hiring an agency for a website rebuild: why start with discovery?

By Nicola Sirchia. Published . 3 minute read.

One-minute version. AI avatar and AI voice, made from my own photo and voice.

The short answer

Don't buy a whole website rebuild on the strength of a pitch. Buy a short, paid discovery first. In a few weeks it gives you customer interviews, an honest look at your data, first requirements and a roadmap, and it shows you how the agency really works before you sign the big contract. If the discovery is weak, you have lost weeks instead of a year.

What goes wrong with the usual pitch?

The agency shows concepts before it knows your customers. You choose the prettiest slide, and the next twelve months are spent building on guesses. Then the people who pitched hand over to a team you never met.

What should a discovery produce?

Five things, and I would not start the build without them.

Who has to be in the room?

More people than you think. Leadership sets the direction. Marketing and communication bring the brand and the stories. Digital and product know what the platform must do. And the business lines, the people who sell and serve, are the ones most often forgotten, and the ones who decide whether the site is used after launch.

BrandguidelinesCustomerinsightHow wemeasureLeadershipsets the directionMarketingbrings brand and storiesDigital and productknow the platformBusiness linesdecide if it gets used
Four groups around the table, three things they must share.

In the middle sit three things every group has to share: the brand guidelines, what customers actually told you, and how success will be measured. If any of the three is missing, each group fills the gap with its own opinion.

How do you judge an agency in a pitch?

These are the questions I listen for.

How would I write the contract?

Discovery as its own phase, with a fixed price and a clear exit. If it delivers, the build runs in sprints with a demo every few weeks. If it does not, you stop, keep everything that was produced, and choose again with far better information.

Where would I start?

  1. Write one page on what the site must do for the business and for customers.
  2. Invite three agencies, and ask each to talk to two of your customers before they pitch.
  3. Buy discovery from the best one, with a fixed price and an exit.
  4. Decide on the build only when you have read the interviews yourself.

Sources

This piece comes from my own work selecting and briefing agencies for website rebuilds. It uses no outside data.