Why do global plans die in local markets?
By Nicola Sirchia. Published . 3 minute read.
The short answer
Most global plans fail for the same reason: the people who have to deliver them had no hand in shaping them. Research by CreativeX found that 90% of global campaign toolkits are never activated by local markets. In my experience the fix is rarely a better toolkit. It is two habits: build with the markets before anything is final, and agree the plan by throwing it back and forth until both sides own it.
What does it look like when a plan dies?
You spend months building the toolkit. Guidelines, templates, the launch film, a playbook for every scenario. You present it in the global call, everybody nods, and the link goes out to all the markets.
Three months later you visit a country and find out they built their own version. Different claims, different visuals. And sometimes, to be fair, it works better than yours.
Targets go the same way. The plan looks great in the presentation in January. By March, the people who have to deliver it are working very quietly on their own priorities.
Why do local teams ignore what the centre builds?
Rarely because they are stubborn. They ignore what doesn't fit their retailers or their budget. A perfect library that nobody opens doesn't help anyone.
What is catchball?
Catchball is a step in Hoshin Kanri, and it is simpler than the Japanese name suggests. Picture two people throwing a ball back and forth.
- 1Leadership throws firstThis is where we need to be
- 2The team throws it backThis is what it would take, and this is what we would have to stop doing
- 3And againUntil both sides own the same plan
I learned it in a Hoshin Kanri programme I ran with a team that ended up beating every target. It is still one of the projects I learned the most from.
What do I do differently now?
- Bring two or three markets in before anything is final. They will sell it to the other markets much better than headquarters ever could.
- Keep it small and easy to adapt.
- Make training part of the launch. A 30-minute session on how to use it in your market does more than another 20 slides.
- Track adoption the way you track sales. A toolkit only starts working the day a market uses it without being asked.
Does the same apply to AI rollouts?
Yes, and I see it often. Strategy says "AI-first". Teams get a licence and a training session. Nobody asks them which part of their week should disappear. Then adoption stalls, and the conclusion is that the technology isn't ready.
Most of the time the technology is fine. The catchball never happened. So before any AI rollout I start from the friction people feel every day, I agree with the team which work stops completely, and I measure the business outcome, not the number of prompts.
A ball that has been thrown back a few times is much harder to drop.
Sources
- Marketing Week, How brands are better aligning global and local teams to avoid waste, reporting the CreativeX research